Friday, October 4, 2013

Menotti: Goya



Wonderful Opera from a Modern Opera Composer
Gian Carlo Menotti is perhaps best known for his wonderful and chilling opera "The Consul". In 1977, Menotti invited Placido Domingo to dinner while the latter was performing in Edinburgh and Domingo asked Menotti if he would write an opera for him - and the agreed upon subject would be Francisco Goya, the Spanish painter. Mr. Menotti chose the Countess of Alba as Goya's love interest (which is not factually accurate), but certainly in this particular production the pairing of Mr. Domingo with Michelle Breedt as the Countess works extremely well indeed. Those two definitely have chemistry! And needless to say, Ms. Breedt is a wonderful singer and is a real treat to hear together with Mr. Domingo.

The opera itself features Iride Martinez as the Queen of Spain, who also desires Goya and is antagonized by the Countess, whom she eventually poisons. The painting scene between Goya and the Countess is playful and the Countess' death scene is particularly powerful and moving...

One of Menotti's last operas worth a look!
This attractive production of one of Menotti's last - and lesser known - operas is well worth checking out. Written expressly for Placido Domingo and premiered in Washington in 1986, Domingo carries the weight of the brilliant but troubled artist quite well. At its premiere, "Goya" actually did not do well in the press. It was beat up a bit for a weak and psychologically scattered libretto, also by the composer (so they say) and for melodies that are quite typical Menotti (which is to say very Puccini-esque) but not very strongly memorable. I did not see that production. My only exposure to this score is the present production, by the Viennese Theatre, under the direction of Kasper Holten and conductor Emmanuel Villaume and I found much to admire. Menotti's Francisco Goya is largely fictional. The painter is seen in a sort of lifelong quest of eternal beauty and begins almost as a Rodolfo from "La Boheme" but ends in madness and despair in what is nearly a "mad scene." The dying...

Nice but...
It is always a pleasure to hear Domingo sing, so there is no surprise that in an Opera composed for him, he excels. But, the opera as a whole is nice, sometimes interesting, but not great. The characters in the plot barely go through any changes. Goya is the only one that has any development during the opera, and the changes are at the beginning of it and then it stops. The music for Goya is very melodic a la Puccini, while for the other characters is a mixed of melody with a touch of atonality. Performers are very good and make the maximum of the available music and plot. The production is rather simple and for a small stage. The sound is stereo only. For those opera lovers, this is an interesting opera and production worth having and watching mostly for curiosity and support of new operas, but it has no "WOW" effect.

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment