Thursday, October 10, 2013

If.... (The Criterion Collection) [Blu-ray]



BLU-RAY EDITION IS A MUST HAVE
Divisive, entrenched, English class struggle is at the heart of Lindsay Anderson's much-lauded but controversial film about students at a private school who revolt against their repressive, bureaucratic environment. Malcolm McDowell is non-conformist Mick Travis who, with his like-minded friends, stages small acts of rebellion and defiance for which they are punished with severe beatings.

At the time of initial release, the movie was considered dangerous and a possible incitement to violence against the powers-that-be. And in many ways, it was (and still is)!

The film was editorialized as a dangerous, irresponsible film (not unlike A CLOCKWORK ORANGE or Z). Edited with jolting but effective use of color and black and white footage, the most famous scene is the surrealistic and bloody student uprising against the reserved, humorless, restrictive adult world. Daring and unpredictable, the film was a great success among the youth of the time and further...

Review of Blu Ray Disc only
I will confine myself to a review of this Criterion Blu Ray Edition.

The transfer is every bit as good as you would expect from Criterion and even if you have the Criterion DVD, its worth the upgrade. The extras are excellent, not least the commentary tracks and booklet. My only hope is that before too much longer Criterion do justice to Oh Lucky Man!

It will leave you saying: "Huh?...."
Outside of some Fellini films, this is probably the most surprised I've been by the low quality of a supposedly fantastic film. It starts out well enough, and you think it's going to be a good public school film, which is right up my alley. I find the forced situation of public school to be unpleasant in reality but fascinating. At a certain point I took a break watching the film and I thought "this is good". The plot wasn't really going anywhere but it seemed to me a nice little slice of these characters and this period in time.

But eventually the film flies off the wheels in a very big way. A faculty member is killed and I was on the edge of my seat. "This is going in a different direction!" I thought. Then in a surreal sequence we see him alive again, and right there the movie kind of dies. Nothing makes sense anymore and nothing matters. I'm very shocked by how many people like this movie. It was I guess a smash when it first came out, another thing that baffles...

Click to Editorial Reviews

No comments:

Post a Comment